On CHOW: How to brine your holiday turkey
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

March 3rd, 2009

$800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple

Posted by Christopher Dawson @ 7:42 am

Categories: Education Technology

Tags: Software, Apple Macintosh, Apple Intel Mac Mini, Apple iLife, Apple Inc., Desktops, Aerospace & Defense, Tools & Techniques, Hardware, Manufacturing

Apple updated it’s line of desktops today, continuing to focus on high-performance, high-efficiency professional machines. Unfortunately, the only model that even gave me pause was their newly lower-priced 20″ iMac ($1199), which might have a place in a multimedia lab.

Unfortunately, even the new Mac Mini, although sporting a new graphics chip, is base-priced at $599 for a configuration with a mere gig of RAM and no monitor. Jumping up to their upgraded “entry-level” desktop sets you back $799 without a monitor.

Obviously, I could leverage academic discounts and probably take $100 off these prices, but once again, Apple has gone further off my educational radar. For that matter, they’re a long ways off my home purchase radar. I wish iLife didn’t work so easily and well; the software suite is the only compelling reason to shell out this sort of money, especially in a home setting.

However, even iLife has its drawbacks in an educational setting. It simply hands so much to the students that they struggle with software (whether Windows, Linux, or even pro-level software on the Mac) that isn’t so brilliantly plug and play. Yes, iLife rocks in many ways, but the level of spoonfeeding it encourages actually makes me think twice about using it widely, especially at the high school level.

So now Apple is offering a range of desktops from $599 to $3299 (low-end Mini to high-end Mac Pro) and not a single one of them makes sense here in Ed Tech land (with the possible exceptions of a pro studio or lab in a university or possibly a high-end lab in a high school setting). I keep hoping that Apple will come through with a truly entry-level desktop or a server product that supports thin clients (like an uber-cheap Mini that automatically configures itself when it’s on a network with a terminal-serving X-Serve). I’m afraid it just isn’t going to happen.

Christopher Dawson

Follow Chris Dawson on Twitter! Christopher Dawson is the technology director for the Athol-Royalston School District in northern Massachusetts and a member of the Internet Press Guild. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations, but always keep in mind that the opinions expressed here are his own and not those of his daytime employer, even if he talks incessantly about his day job.

Email Christopher Dawson

Subscribe to ZDNet Education via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 57 Talkback(s)
Spoon-feeding bend my elbow
"iLife rocks in many ways, but the level of spoonfeeding it encourages
actually makes me think twice about using it widely, especially at the
high school level."

Oh, my. Would hate that students actually concentrate on content rather
than technology fixes and workarounds.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Partners in Grime Posted on: 03/06/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Business strategy  per@... | 03/03/09
RE: Business Strategy  SDWolf | 03/03/09
False premise  frgough | 03/03/09
lol at this one, i mean honestly...  gnesterenko | 03/03/09
Holy horse crap batman!  Martin Pilkington | 03/03/09
Holy horse crap batman!  webzilla | 03/03/09
The fact that you read this story...  bbneo | 03/03/09
Speaking of paying more...  MGP2 | 03/03/09
Beg to differ  piperdown | 03/04/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  PChicago | 03/03/09
Nattering Peevishness.  public@... | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  PFFXV | 03/03/09
Exactly, you can get plenty of PC performance for half that these days.  T1Oracle | 03/03/09
Can you find a similarly priced pc thats as sexy and slim?  ChrisOPeterson | 03/03/09
Sexy? What is sexy to you?  public@... | 03/03/09
Ha!  djmik | 03/03/09
GEEK? Are you calling me a geek?  public@... | 03/03/09
What's that about...  MGP2 | 03/03/09
What exactly are you looking for?  VIPv6 | 03/03/09
$599 for a thin client with no monitor?  hamobu | 03/03/09
ah, it's about great value...  Pederson | 03/03/09
Because cheaper is better?  lundp@... | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  sbesedick | 03/03/09
"Spoonfeeding" my foot  chancock2 | 03/03/09
A dirty little secret  frgough | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  jzone | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  deowll | 03/03/09
Ok, I'm stupid, foolish, naive...  pairof9s | 03/03/09
And have a blast doing it!  deowll | 03/03/09
Actually that's $650, not $800  Michael Kelly | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  crazydanr@... | 03/03/09
I get the feeling  Kid Icarus-21097050858087920245213802267493 | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  Matthewb02 | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  chris250480 | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  stevejg61 | 03/03/09
Makes no sense  lundp@... | 03/03/09
Makes no sense  lundp@... | 03/03/09
Well,  Kid Icarus-21097050858087920245213802267493 | 03/03/09
Really, what is the reason?  lundp@... | 03/03/09
17" iMac available for EDU  pman1891 | 03/03/09
Chris you keep flogging the Idea  CowLauncher | 03/03/09
"somehow"  TripleII | 03/03/09
You really stomped the pro-Apple crowd.  TripleII | 03/03/09
Well, I gave it TWO thumbs up!  MGP2 | 03/03/09
Lol, I voted it up too.  TripleII | 03/04/09
I'm curious about something...  MGP2 | 03/04/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  ewelch | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  mattjumbo | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  ceolaf | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  TechTeach_z | 03/03/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  kaleberg | 03/03/09
Bass Ackwards!  tmsmqwx | 03/03/09
Maybe they do more than movies and photo's?  TripleII | 03/04/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  DougMeinhardt | 03/04/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  piperdown | 03/04/09
RE: $800 Mac Mini? I'm all set, Apple  Pat Barr | 03/05/09
Spoon-feeding bend my elbow  Partners in Grime | 03/06/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here