On TechRepublic: 10 dying IT skills
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

June 17th, 2009

Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States

Posted by Christopher Dawson @ 4:17 pm

Categories: Education Technology

Tags: Ubuntu, Metasys, Linux, Desktops, UNIX, Operating Systems, Open Source, Software, Hardware, Christopher Dawson

I just finished reading Dana Blankenhorn’s post, “Will Ubuntu remain a minor player” on a break between interviews and meetings. Interestingly, just before I read his post, I met with the President of Metasys, a Brazilian company that has Linux-based servers, desktops, and software in thousands of schools, businesses, and homes throughout Latin America, Africa, and Europe. Metasys is running on 350,000 desktops in Brazil alone. And guess what? People pay for it because it’s good; it has a great ecosystem of server, software, and management products; and because it’s still drastically cheaper than Windows.

While Dana’s post specifically addressed Ubuntu, he might as well have been asking if Linux would always be a marginal player on the desktop. If I have learned nothing else by attending the Classmate Eco System Summit it’s that there are a lot of people outside the United States doing a lot of incredibly innovative things in education and that many of them are doing it cheaply with Linux.

So-called “emerging markets” (which, at this rate, won’t be emerging for long, and will quickly become “overtaking markets”) are rolling out a variety of operating systems and engaging in really progressive learning models. Worldwide, there are 13 million active Ubuntu users with use growing faster than any other distribution. Check out these trends from Google gauging online interest (with breakdowns by region).

In many places, people (far more than the 300 million in the US) are buying their first computers with no preconceptions about what an OS should be. As these markets explode, one has to wonder if our perception that the US is the only market that matters to operating system vendors will change. Microsoft gets it; they are putting incredible amounts of pressure on governments in Brazil to compete with Metasys and are largely proving unsuccessful (this is only one example, of course; Microsoft is working very aggressively in countless other markets and had a vocal presence at the first full day of the Summit).

In China, Ubuntu is gaining traction quickly since, due to rampant piracy, Windows is essentially free in that country. New users are choosing operating systems based on merit rather than price, since price is largely irrelevant in that market.

So perhaps Ubuntu, and Linux in general will struggle to gain market share on the desktop in the States for now, particularly since Windows 7 looks to be a decent operating system. We need to remember, though, that the US is not the only PC market in the world. In fact, it’s a shrinking, saturated market. When many of the international partners with whom we work in this global economy find Windows and Linux to be equally legitimate (or even favor Linux because of its openness and low cost or free software), what will happen to desktop Linux here?

Even as companies like HP and Dell continue to legitimize Ubuntu through high-quality offerings on their netbooks, I think we’ll see a shift here in the States. It’s just that the shift Stateside won’t matter all that much globally given the size of this market relative to what we now call emerging markets.

Christopher Dawson

Follow Chris Dawson on Twitter! Christopher Dawson is the technology director for the Athol-Royalston School District in northern Massachusetts and a member of the Internet Press Guild. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations, but always keep in mind that the opinions expressed here are his own and not those of his daytime employer, even if he talks incessantly about his day job.

Email Christopher Dawson

Subscribe to ZDNet Education via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 151 Talkback(s)
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States
Ubuntu, Red Hat, etc are all crazy, incompatible Linux versions. WINE (windows emulator) comes in ten versions for the crazy Linux stuff. It doesn't work, since the a private developer (Crossover) ha... (Read the rest)
Posted by: gregzeng@... Posted on: 11/17/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Agreed, with one minor point difference . . .  JLHenry | 06/17/09
Not to mention  NStalnecker | 06/17/09
It's called...  zkiwi | 06/17/09
The Kanji character  rikasa | 06/17/09
Je suis de la Nouvelle-Z?lande  zkiwi | 06/18/09
Red Flag - (beat me to it) (nt)  Economister | 06/17/09
Ah  NStalnecker | 06/17/09
Forgot all about that one!!! Good Catch!! (nt)  JLHenry | 06/18/09
Your absolutely lying about Ubuntu, they couldn't gaim market share  lightingrod | 06/17/09
If sarcasm - well done. If not, you're in trouble (nt)  Economister | 06/17/09
He/She's in trouble! (nt)  InAction Man | 06/18/09
Believe me...  yschoo1@... | 06/18/09
lightingrod  carlleigh@... | 06/17/09
LMFO  gnesterenko | 06/18/09
You dont get quality things for free  digish777 | 06/18/09
Exactly! If you want good sunshine or clean fresh air prepare to pay up!  InAction Man | 06/18/09
but how are you measuring " free"?  sunworks | 06/19/09
My Hospital Uses Windows 2k...  windozefreak | 06/19/09
Not Quite  PoohPall | 06/18/09
Awesome.....  spartan2276 | 06/18/09
Maybe  The_Quietman | 06/19/09
LOOK EVERYONE!@#*@)#@!!! HE MENTIONS ME!!@*@*@*@!!  Loverock Davidson | 06/19/09
HI LOVIE, NICE TO SEE YOU FOUND REFERENCE TO YOUR KNOWLEDGE  lightingrod | 06/20/09
A cut and paste of my comment on Dana's blog  Economister | 06/17/09
saying "what happened"? not all of us...  shryko | 06/19/09
Thanks  zkiwi | 06/17/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  olddogv | 06/17/09
I have done the same on my machines..  yschoo1@... | 06/18/09
13 Million Equals...  clindhartsen | 06/17/09
not important anymore  gertruded | 06/18/09
What planet or time are you from?  stano360 | 06/18/09
I think you missed something.  deowll | 06/18/09
13 Million is a Billion $ M$ did not get  pogson | 06/18/09
Gosh, Windows-fans keep saying only 1% for Linux desktops  bswiss | 06/19/09
Also, Android (Linux) on Arm Netbooks outperforms Win7 on Intel.  DonnieBoy | 06/17/09
only "When Android did work"  markbn | 06/17/09
But, did you read that Android on Arm outperforms Win7 on Intel????  DonnieBoy | 06/18/09
Have they released the report already?  markbn | 06/18/09
Problems of not working were due to bleeding edge new hardware, nothing  DonnieBoy | 06/19/09
Your blind optimism is astonishing  de-void | 06/19/09
Well, Windos 7 may work on netbooks, but, it is looking like it will be  DonnieBoy | 06/19/09
Wanna be's  The Management consultant | 06/18/09
Moving on  gertruded | 06/18/09
You need to think again.  deowll | 06/18/09
I'm brazilian and nobody likes Linux here in Brazil  maxgomes | 06/18/09
The vast number of different Brazilian Linux distros prove you wrong!  InAction Man | 06/18/09
The best developers are here, in Brazil  maxgomes | 06/18/09
Americans believe that you get what you pay for  InAction Man | 06/18/09
That is quite a stretch  GuidingLight | 06/18/09
NoAxe, what a strange worldview you have.  nizuse | 06/18/09
One shared by the VAST MAJORITY. You are the tiny minority.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
yawn.  nizuse | 06/18/09
I take it you mean...  zkiwi | 06/18/09
Americans also . . .  JLHenry | 06/19/09
Vast?  Stan57 | 06/18/09
23 Brazilian Linux distros, that IS a vast number, don't you agree?  InAction Man | 06/18/09
why do you need so many distros  thefinisher | 06/18/09
I don't! No one does!  InAction Man | 06/19/09
Duh  Stan57 | 06/19/09
Talented people use linux???hahaha  pcavalcanti | 06/18/09
Read post 9.1.2.1. above  InAction Man | 06/18/09
Sorry, but...  eMJayy | 06/18/09
It Still...  windozefreak | 06/19/09
Re: Sorry, but  Stan57 | 06/19/09
You must be mistaken.  InAction Man | 06/19/09
You got the main idea but this is a sad history....  maxgomes | 06/18/09
Red hat has pretty good support  thefinisher | 06/18/09
He may have a point  PCLinuxOS(user) | 06/21/09
Ubuntu in Brazil  thefinisher | 06/18/09
Google Trends against windows versions  Spats30 | 06/18/09
actually  gnesterenko | 06/18/09
In most countries it would appear to be a major player.  deowll | 06/18/09
And its still. not even a minor player  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
No_Ax  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
Good luck on that!  B.O.F.H. | 06/18/09
A small analogy  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
I've never written that MS is 'evil'  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
But, its no one's job to show them the Quad  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
I am suggesting  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
And the facts disagree...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
Other than one Wal-Mart example  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
@Dietrich  eb276 | 06/18/09
@eb276: hmmmmmm. hmmmmmmmm. wink  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
@Dietrich  InAction Man | 06/18/09
@InactionMan: I see what you mean. But I am not sure.  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
@Dietrich  eb276 | 06/18/09
@eb276: Oh yes. Of course. I remember now. How are you Earl?  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
@Dietrich  eb276 | 06/18/09
@eb276: Doing well. Thank you so much for asking.  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
However...  zkiwi | 06/18/09
Spurious  daengbo | 06/19/09
Just not true  stano360 | 06/18/09
ubuntu  kikl | 06/18/09
Tell it like it is kikl!!!!!!!!! happy  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
nd yet, no one wants it and is why it only has 1%  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
Close but not quite  stano360 | 06/18/09
Hold Your Breath...  windozefreak | 06/19/09
Sorry Christopher, you are attempting to legitimize  GuidingLight | 06/18/09
Agreed, it doesn't even rate as a minor player.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
The more you talk, the more wrong you are.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
Yes, I would like to clarify  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
No, you are wrong  eb276 | 06/18/09
They took the chance, it FAILED. End of story.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
Can't, Linux FAILED in retail stores and was tossed out.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
And why do you hide from the fact 80% of PCs  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/18/09
That's zero (0) citations so far. Any takers?  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
You would have better luck with on-line sources.  B.O.F.H. | 06/18/09
Thanks B.O.F.H. Citation Count stands at zero (0)  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
The install process with Ubuntu is sort of unique.  B.O.F.H. | 06/18/09
Not sure I follow you. Clarify please on:  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
During the set-up/install process, only a user account is created.  B.O.F.H. | 06/18/09
Learn more  daengbo | 06/19/09
Thanks daengbo, I will have to try that out!  B.O.F.H. | 06/19/09
Dell is the answer  kikl | 06/18/09
That was the right answer to the wrong question. But you get credit  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/18/09
spot on!  kikl | 06/18/09
Well less than Minor !!  Aussie_Troll | 06/18/09
Locally correct, Globally wrong  Narg | 06/18/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  oscare.ramirezp | 06/18/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  deefburger | 06/18/09
America is not the world  nickpotgieter | 06/18/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  taylorjh1@... | 06/18/09
Inteligent techies  mist27@... | 06/18/09
Troll money  tonymcs@... | 06/18/09
Entire state Govts in India use Ubuntu  iRMX | 06/18/09
Applications, Applications, Applications  Kaiwai | 06/18/09
route account / sudo  kikl | 06/19/09
Good point. One small nit  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/19/09
Average user Applications  kikl | 06/19/09
Re: Average user Applications  notsofast | 06/19/09
RE: Applications  Stan57 | 06/19/09
Guys, please hink outside the box, USA is not the whole world!  washington.rodriguez | 06/19/09
Hurray for washington.rodriguez!!!!!!!!! Good Point.  Dietrich T. Schmitz | 06/19/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  Loverock Davidson | 06/19/09
Your posts get deleted  nizuse | 06/19/09
Doing charity again?  InAction Man | 06/20/09
If you are not from the US and you want to trust an American company ....  Felix Derzhinsky | 06/20/09
Re: 80% and other "Facts"  grax | 06/20/09
Agreed  shoshonski | 06/20/09
Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  interested_amateur@... | 06/20/09
About time!!  Nookawarra | 07/01/09
Ubuntu is very popular in Brazil  renatobovo@... | 06/21/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  jfreedle2@... | 06/25/09
Because it's Free - Or Very Cheap  jpr75_z | 07/06/09
red flag linux, nobody cares and nobody uses  FADS_z | 07/06/09
Ubuntu vs 7 Ultimate  wrcflier@... | 07/06/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  ditkazbearz | 07/06/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  ditkazbearz | 07/06/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  sailor 2001 | 07/07/09
Ubuntu? What's that. Something that runs a toaster perhaps?  transposeIT | 07/15/09
RE: Ubuntu a minor player? Not outside the States  gregzeng@... | 11/17/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors
advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More