On mySimon: Fundamentals Kit First Aid & Supplies
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

August 17th, 2009

Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!

Posted by Christopher Dawson @ 12:09 pm

Categories: Education Technology

Tags: College Student, Music, Christopher Dawson

This message is for kids, certainly, college students, and schools. File sharing is bad. I don’t care where you stand on the modernization of copyright law - the courts have spoken and now the Department of Justice has spoken. According to a piece in PC Magazine (and covered extensively elsewhere),

…in establishing that range, Congress took into account the need to deter millions of users of new media from infringing copyrights in an environment where many violators believe that they will go unnoticed.

This quote was taken from a brief written by the DOJ explaining that $80,000 a song was an acceptable penalty for file sharing and copyright infringement among run-of-the-mill Kazaa users.

My kids know better than to download and share music; I’ve certainly lectured them enough and they use their allowances and money from jobs to purchase music. However, even at home, I’ve blocked all ports associated with peer-to-peer networks.

As I was reimaging PCs the other day at our high school, I found a few on which students had managed to install peer-to-peer file sharing software (apparently they’ve discovered those wonderful administrator cracking live CDs, too). Fortunately, our new firewall and some tweaks to Group Policy should stop this nonsense in its tracks.

However, the significance of this latest ruling can’t be emphasized enough to students and needs to be enforced vigorously on our networks. Want to download the latest Ubuntu ISO via torrents? Tough. Do it via http.

RIAA has already said it won’t go after individual file sharers anymore and, while I’m somewhat skeptical about that, even if it’s true that leaves schools and businesses who allow P2P on their networks wide open to liability. Shut it down, folks. Educate parents about how to shut it down and educate your students on the real possibility of litigation if they continue downloading and sharing songs. Perhaps the entertainment industry and copyright law will catch up with the Digital Revolution, but for now people are just being bankrupted.

Christopher Dawson

Follow Chris Dawson on Twitter! Christopher Dawson is the technology director for the Athol-Royalston School District in northern Massachusetts and a member of the Internet Press Guild. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations, but always keep in mind that the opinions expressed here are his own and not those of his daytime employer, even if he talks incessantly about his day job.

Email Christopher Dawson

Subscribe to ZDNet Education via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 169 Talkback(s)
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!
People have been copying music since reel to reel
tapes were invented. This accelerated when cassettes
came out and continued when cheap CD's and CD writers
became available. Now we have... (Read the rest)
Posted by: stuart@... Posted on: 09/03/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
A bit naive?  Economister | 08/17/09
When you don't like the price...  cornpie | 08/17/09
Absurd Nonsense  Economister | 08/17/09
still legitimate conduct?  mdemuth | 08/17/09
You made your point against yourself  GuidingLight | 08/17/09
Your analogy of  xXSpeedzXx | 08/17/09
So where, exactly, is the theft?  aep528 | 08/17/09
Theft is a moral concept  frgough | 08/17/09
Stupidly simplistic  Economister | 08/17/09
Its a war for Openess  Oldarney | 08/19/09
@Oldarney  oncall | 08/19/09
@ aep528  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
Know what's going on before you comment.  robbieharrison@... | 08/18/09
THAT is an incorrect analogy  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
Your nonsense is absurd.  bjbrock | 08/17/09
Could some of the posters above,.......  Economister | 08/17/09
That's not a difficult one to answer  PlayFair | 08/17/09
Really?  Economister | 08/17/09
I agree with you..govt is the problem  otaddy | 08/17/09
And if the RIAA gets its way, it WILL be forever (nt)  Economister | 08/17/09
@ Economister  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
@ M.R. Kennedy  Economister | 08/17/09
LOL Kennedy  oncall | 08/18/09
Yes, really  zdnet-gregc | 08/19/09
Illegally downloading copyrighted material is not always civil disobedience  zdnet-gregc | 08/19/09
stop buying... I like it.  exolon | 08/20/09
To all those carrying on, read this...  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
So let me ask you this.  IT_Guy_z | 08/17/09
See my reply above (nt)  Economister | 08/17/09
@ Economister (again)  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
Clueless (again) nt  Economister | 08/17/09
re: Clueless (again)  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
No  Economister | 08/17/09
Think of this then  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
Just because you find a law trivial and stupid  xXSpeedzXx | 08/17/09
Tell that to the banks, credit card companies , etc  kd5auq | 08/17/09
Do you have citation for such claims  xXSpeedzXx | 08/17/09
How about this...  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
What a load of BS  GuidingLight | 08/17/09
What is to catch up.  bjbrock | 08/17/09
Not true....  linux for me | 08/17/09
Hang them I say.  fr0thy2 | 08/17/09
They're being bankrupted because they choose...  ye | 08/17/09
Simple. Stop *buying* music  wolf_z | 08/17/09
Punishment doesn't fit the crime.  bmonsterman | 08/17/09
If I understand the case correctly  brble | 08/17/09
It's not fair to compare this to actual goods though  bmonsterman | 08/17/09
They're not the same...  brble | 08/18/09
That's doubtful  alex@... | 08/20/09
Even that comparison holds no weight  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  brhubart@... | 08/17/09
Stop calling it "sharing", it is not yours to share.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/17/09
I agree!  HypnoToad72 | 08/17/09
Well the artist get zero from the RIAA lawsuits...  mrlinux | 08/18/09
That is between the artist and the record company  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/18/09
go ahead  robbieharrison@... | 08/18/09
Sorry, not mine to share  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/18/09
I'm not convinced it's that simple...  alkanshel | 08/19/09
Not quite  Caggles | 08/18/09
No Ax would still be sitting in the back of the bus.  Bodazapha | 08/18/09
Only as I wave to your prison bus.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/18/09
Better to Live Defiantly for what I consider fair  Bodazapha | 08/18/09
Lol - yeah tell him!  CounterEthicsCommissioner | 08/18/09
@ CounterEthicsCommissioner  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
@M.R. K  Bodazapha | 08/18/09
Folks who risked life and limb...  oncall | 08/18/09
Ahhh so Civil disobedience is ONLY allowed if we risk our lives....  Bodazapha | 08/18/09
Then what are you doing for it?  oncall | 08/18/09
Not so cut and dry there Don  Robert Crocker | 08/18/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  gertruded | 08/17/09
Amen  Economister | 08/17/09
Sick to my stomach  PlayFair | 08/17/09
Maybe this will make you feel better  Economister | 08/17/09
Public Domain  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
Another one from the left field (nt)  Economister | 08/17/09
Hardly  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
Wow  Droid101 | 08/18/09
re: Wow  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
When you actually comprehend...  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
How many people can't afford $.99?  PlayFair | 08/21/09
You still haven't answered anything.  PlayFair | 08/17/09
Did you post a question for someone somewhere? (nt)  Economister | 08/17/09
Yes, the question is...  PlayFair | 08/17/09
Finally an enlightened discussion.  Economister | 08/17/09
Long, rambling rant  frgough | 08/17/09
Clearly beyond your comprehension (nt)  Economister | 08/17/09
@ frgough  M.R. Kennedy | 08/17/09
Strange indeed  Economister | 08/17/09
Classic ignorant retort to a well thought out response  Bodazapha | 08/18/09
Its called public domain  cornpie | 08/17/09
Okay, then, let's restore the public domain  raindog469 | 08/17/09
Well said. (nt)  Economister | 08/17/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  ansak | 08/17/09
A few things:  CobraA1 | 08/17/09
Reform filesharers and govt  Boot_Agnostic | 08/18/09
I'll stop sharing now  homeblend | 08/18/09
Never Stop sharing! Never!  monctonjohn | 08/18/09
hey hey hey there would you please stop this my god  Quebec-french | 08/18/09
Hot  monctonjohn | 08/18/09
Where are you from?  Dauplat | 08/19/09
Samll Minded Response  monctonjohn | 08/20/09
More to add  monctonjohn | 08/20/09
Well if so much illegal file sharing is going on...  mrlinux | 08/18/09
Legal alternative  homeblend | 08/18/09
linuxiso.org  mrlinux | 08/18/09
Legal Downloads  john.lemme@... | 08/18/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  super_J | 08/18/09
Just because it's illegal doesn't mean it's wrong.  mrdt | 08/18/09
Agreed  Caggles | 08/18/09
@ mrdtr: Just because it's illegal...  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
RE: Mr Kennedy  homeblend | 08/19/09
Er...  alkanshel | 08/19/09
re: Stealing  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
RE Stealing v2.0r32443  homeblend | 08/19/09
re: Stealing v2.0r32443  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
Sigh  oncall | 08/19/09
RE: Music is free  homeblend | 08/19/09
@homeblend  oncall | 08/19/09
@ robbieharrison  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
That makes no sense  alkanshel | 08/18/09
re: That makes no sense  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
The mercedes argument is still lame  Caggles | 08/18/09
re: The mercedes argument is still lame  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
yes, they are outlawing backups  robbieharrison@... | 08/18/09
Not quite, and not quite yet  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  PlayFair | 08/18/09
@ PlayFair  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
Bravo  oncall | 08/19/09
The Three Honest Persons  Bob C User | 08/25/09
@ oncall  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
Sorry happy  oncall | 08/18/09
@ Economister (Strange indeed)  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
@ Bodazapha  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
M.R. Kennedy  robbieharrison@... | 08/18/09
Don't waste your time on him. He's clueless as usual (nt)  Economister | 08/18/09
Speaking of wasting time...  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
Back atcha, robbie.  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
Kennedy, reread 20.2  robbieharrison@... | 08/19/09
robbieharrison, research 2.0  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
so you DO understand...  robbieharrison@... | 08/20/09
I will agree...  oncall | 08/20/09
re: so you DO understand...  M.R. Kennedy | 08/20/09
Non-value added article  terry flores | 08/18/09
Perhaps...  M.R. Kennedy | 08/18/09
Black and White  Bodazapha | 08/18/09
RE: Black and White  homeblend | 08/19/09
There is no "free lunch"  oncall | 08/19/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  gorgon@... | 08/19/09
@ gorgon  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  jacrisostomo | 08/19/09
Changing times...  M.R. Kennedy | 08/19/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  iouzero | 08/19/09
Creative commons and Public Domain  staalmannen | 08/19/09
Finally, someone with a good idea.  PlayFair | 08/20/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  smtp4me@... | 08/20/09
@smtp4me - That's exactly the attitude...  PlayFair | 08/20/09
@smtp4me - That's exactly the attitude...  smtp4me@... | 08/20/09
The bottom line  oncall | 08/20/09
I guess most people here forget one tiny little detail...  vbp1 | 08/20/09
Question for everyone...  PlayFair | 08/20/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  larissa860 | 08/20/09
Let's get some more quotes in here  oncall | 08/20/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  larissa860 | 08/20/09
He may be lost...  oncall | 08/20/09
Oh, fiddle dee-dee  kaninelupus | 08/21/09
Let's be serious for a minute.  PlayFair | 08/21/09
Sigh...  robbieharrison@... | 08/21/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  Manny J | 08/31/09
RE: Let me say it again: Stop sharing music!  stuart@... | 09/03/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More